Wednesday, March 04, 2026

Walking in a city designed for cars

Bill Bryson has written about his experiments in trekking, and his attempts to walk in a typical American city, which, if you go by his experience, is almost impossible. Nobody in the USA, least none of all the developers and Town Planners, can think of any reason why people would walk in a city when there are cars available. There are hardly any footpaths, and the ones that are there in places like downtown market areas, end up abruptly at some point without any warning, and you are left stranded, wondering whether you can walk on the road, which is really a very dangerous thing to do, as no motorist expects any pedestrians on the streets, it would be very difficult to avoid a crash.

The exceptions are there, of course. The most populous cities in US, like New York and San Francisco for example, have a large network of public transport and look like any populous city in India, with crowded streets, roadside amenities and parks and pedestrians rule in the city.

But this picture changes drastically once you go to any tier 2 or tier 3 city. Public transport is almost non-existent once you leave the large metropolitan cities, and walking anywhere is not at all a good option. 

That is the reason USA is mostly a nation of car-owners (about 1.88 cars per household) and people regularly take their cars to a stadium or some such place if they want to walk as an exercise, park their cars, and walk on the grounds. It is not at all practical to walk for daily work, or to visit a grocery shop, unless you live in the central part of the city.

Before my son Pranav came to USA, and started working in Jacksonville FL, I was not even aware that it existed. Though geographically the largest city in the USA, Jacksonville is almost unheard of in India. There is no reason for it to be famous the world over anyway. No US Presidents have ever come from Jacksonville, nor it has any architectural or natural wonders or for that matter not even any negative publicity. Florida as a state is holiday destination because of its beaches, but the most famous is Miami, not Jacksonville. The only time Florida came in news when the automatic counting of votes became an issue in the famous Bush vs Gore elections, but this is not a matter of interest to people outside US.

When I visited Jacksonville in 2009, I found that the this was a city of followers in matters of architectural style, not leaders. The downtown buildings tried a faithful copy of buildings from New York, while the residential architecture in the suburbs was a distinct copy of typical British houses of Victorian era. Later I even found a treatise on Heritage of Jacksonville in the local library, but it was mostly about people. This was my first visit to USA and frankly I did not know what to expect. Having lived in India all my life, I had some idea about the most famous cities of USA like New York and San Francisco but was not aware of the day-to-day life in any of these cities.

Friday, October 21, 2011

Italy Trip Part 2

What struck me as I moved the narrow streets of Florence & Pisa that the towns looked exactly the way they were built a few hundred years ago. I recollect the comment by P. G. Wodehouse describing 'Market Blandings', a fictional village. "Sometime in the early 16th century", Wodehouse writes, "the master mason took down his tools, and said to his mates-'this is Market Blandings', and no one has touched it since." I was wondering whether this was a true state of affairs anywhere, as I have never been to England, and know for a fact that this can not happen in India, but Pisa & Florence have lived up the comment literally.

What is most heartening is that the planners in Italy have not tried to remodel these places on the lines of some hypothetical development norms, the way we try to do in India. When I was a part of the Planning Committee at Aurangabad, the planners told me that the exercise would involve planning amenities for the old city too, based on the population, and also a traffic & transportation planning based on current requirements. The exercise therefore involved earmarking places for schools, hospitals & so on in the already crowded city, and widening of streets in the old city to allow more traffic. The resultant plan paved the way for destruction of the old city - both in form & spirit.

In contrast, the Italian historic cities have tried to accommodate the present day requirements without compromising on the historic character. The streets in Florence are not wide, hence they have devised a network of one-way streets, instead of widening the existing roads. The towns now attract a large amount of tourist traffic, and the earlier houses are converted into hotels. I actually lived in such re-modelled houses in both Pisa & Florence. The conversion was done tastefully, modern amenities like electrification & plumbing was added, all without disturbing the original fabric of the building. If ever there was a demonstration of how you treat your heritage buildings, this was it.

We keep on saying that India has the greatest living heritage, but in practice, hardly any of that sentiment is visible. We need to imbibe some of the spirit of the Italains to do justice to our own heritage at home.

Wednesday, June 08, 2011

Italy Trip

It was only when I stood in the Piazza of St. Peters that I was reminded of the fact that I was a third world architect, experiencing for the first time the huge scale of architecture of the western civilisation.

Indian architecture, in contrast, tries to bring down the scale, by subdividing the large spaces in small chunks, and detailing them on a still smaller scale. The huge forecourt of Tajmahal, just to quote an example, is sub-divided into four quarters, and then again with the small strip of water running through, with a hard edge and flower beds alonside, it brings down the space to a humane level. So the overall effect is a series of small spaces joined together in a large space, but the hugeness of the larger space is broken by multiple visual elements.

The detailing of the building follows the same pattern. The entire edifice is subdivided in multiple frames, and each frame is again divided by the intricate carved patterns.

In contrast, the scale of St. Peters is intimidating, and unbroken save the huge obelisk in the middle and the two fountains on the side, all of which does not break the space, but enhances the feeling of hugeness of the piazza.

In the structure too, the columns rise to a great height, without any treatment (not even the volutes) and enhance the feeling of hugeness. The decorative motifs are reserved for the base and the capital only, and here again, the base has only the plain mouldings, which is the only treatment at human level, while the capitals are treated with intricate carving, but they are far too distant from the eye level, and even if they reduce the impact of hugeness, and make the assembly seem lightweight, already the distance has its impact, enchancing the feeling of scale.

Standing in the forcourt of St. Peters, I could understand the impact it had on Le Corbusier, and its re-incarnation as the fourecourt of the Chandigad Capital Complex. No wonder then, that there have been umpteen attempts by the Indian architectural fraternity to give it a meaning by subdividing the scale of this court to bring it to a humane level, on the lines of indian monuments - while the monumental scale of such spaces has fascinated western architects and it re-surfaces in its various avtars - be it the Salk Institute or IIM Ahmedabad.

Sunday, May 09, 2010

Teaching Design

When Ms. Rashmi Baluja, one of my students from MIT, Aurangabad, and now a design teacher, posted a topic on her facebook page titled "What is the importance of Design in Teaching architecture" I could not resist the urge to reply that Architectural education is all about design. I have very high regards for Rashmi - she was one of my brightest students once, and I could not understand why somebody like her in her right mind should put so obvious a question as a topic for discussion.

I then realised that what is obvious to me may not be so in other peoples' eyes. In fact I have not seen teachers in schools of architecture taking any great effort to relate their subjects to design in any way. So if Design is the core subject in architecture, it is probably only the people who made the syllabus (and, of course, the COA) who know this.

And then there are problem with the teaching of design itself. The problem is that we are trying to convert the process of design exclusively into some kind of craft - by taking up basic design, trying to analyse shapes & forms and so on. I have seen many good teachers engrossed in this, sincerely hoping that they are creating the proper foundation for architectural design. I have seen them later frustated by the fact that none of these exercises translate into architectual design in the third & fourth year.

Why should this happen? Is not architecture about for interesting forms & spaces? We all seem to presume that the students have an innate desire to create beautiful spaces, and our job is only to streamline that. But on an everyday basis, I have seen that the students seem to be totally confused as to what is expected of them in the design studio.

The issue is much deeper than the simplistic thinking done presently. Some of the visiting teachers come to the design studio with an idea that their job is only to comment on what is wrong in the design - as if that would somehow make the student better in design. There are others who discuss only the functional issues and building bye-laws and so on, so much so that in a design studio, all the design solutions eventually develop like variations of a singular theme. And then these same teachers complain that the students do not have any originality.

The third approach, giving space to students and relying on their initiative (an experiment I did in the first few years at MIT) has not worked for me, as most of the students (with many activities outside the college) just loiter around, doing nothing, and then try to finish the job hastily in the last few weeks of the term.

How does one go about solving this issue?

I think we can take a cue from other creative disciplines like art. In an art school, you have to teach the students how to hold a brush, the colour wheel and the history of art and so on - but when it comes to a fresh new subject for a painting, the student will respond by creating exactly what he understands about the world around him.

I was going through a lecture on TED by Thelma Golden, an african-american curator of a museum wherein she described how art expanded her vision of the world - in fact that is the ultimate purpose of art in my opinion.

A creative artist is not somebody who knows how to paint, but also what to paint and to do that he has to interpret the world - and create his version of the world as he understands it. He must know his context and must be able to analyse it and put forward his impressions. This can not happen if the artist lives by himself in a ghetto of his making.

This is exactly what is happening to the students of architecture today. Architectural education has become very costly, not everybody can afford it. Those who do, most probably were sepearted from their fellow beings at the stage of kindergarten, going through a very elite schooling till they came to architecture, and their worldview is limited to what can be seen on the TV & the internet.

I am not blaming anybody here, I am just stating a fact. What we need to do is to give exposure of the real world to all these students - India in fact is a great place when it comes to originality in design. But we need to understand our world and try to interpret it - that is how design originates.
So the stress in the design studio must be on the understanding of the issue by the students and his interpretation in text form - a medium we seem to have forgotten in architecture. But about this I think I should delve in in the next blog.

Monday, August 03, 2009

Guggenheim NY

I was in J. J. as a student in the seventies and like most other colleges of architecture at the time, 'Fountainhead' was much talked about novel of the day. Howard Roark is a typical Ayn Rand hero, but the philosophy he talks about is all borrowed from Frank Lloyd Wright. (FLW)How many students of architecture saw FLW as a hero is a moot point-we were all zapped by the character build-up of the hero by Ayn Rand.

The problem with Ayn Rand or for that matter anybody who wrote about FLW is a problem of straight-jacketing. FLW was a genius, bracketing him into an 'ism' is meaningless. I have seen him listed as a part of 'Art & crafts' because he fits very well in the chronology, and his prairie houses praised as a return to the craft tradition. I have also seen him described as the father of the modern movement-celebrating the machine age. For those who are aware that 'Arts & crafts' was a movement based on nostalgia and was opposed to the changes brought in by industrialisation would see the contradiction here. There has been-to the best of my knowledge-very little attempt by historians to clarify this confusion.

When I visited Guggenheim Museum in New York, all this came back to me, when I tried to explain my son Pranav (who is an IT Consultant & not an architect), the importance of this particular building in the history of architecture. We had just been to Buffalo, where we visited the 'Martin House' by FLW, and the contrast in the actual form of the two buildings by FLW could not be greater.

It is very difficult to perceive that the Guggenheim Museum is designed by the same person who did the prairie houses, but this is true of most of the work of FLW. If we compare this with his contemporaries & even the great architects of the later period, most of them are known to be fond of certain configurations of built form/detailing/colour/texture & so on, which they have repeated from one project to another. What somebody would call a 'signature tune'. FLW seems to be content without any such thing.

What struck me however, was the universal character of the form of Guggenheim. Here (rarely for FLW) was a building conceived purely as an art form-independent of the context. It looks now completely in contrast with its surroundings. If you discount the great central park (which you can not see for the compound wall anyway), all the buildings in the layout are strictly rectangular, the layout itself is the typical grid-iron of all American cities, and even the terrain is reasonably level, so there is no change of scene. It would seem that FLW was consciously seeking a contrast but knowing that he tried with the octagon first, his curves must have come in as design development and not as a basic idea of contrasting form of curved shell.

Incidentally, when I visited Guggenheim, they were celebrating 50th anniversary of the building (It was built in 1959), and had put up the exhibition of FLW's work in the Museum. It contained drawings, photographs & models and many small sketches & perspectives done by FLW. They had also on display many working drawings done in FLW's office.

The building is a continuous curved ramp making up a total of five levels, with a huge skylight on top-and what I wanted to check is whether the continuous ramp makes viewing of objects difficult. It does. Though the diameter is very large, there is a sensation of a slope which is not convenient at all when you are trying to view an object of art-or for that matter any exhibit.
This of-course is not the only problem with the building. The floor slopes up to make way for a skylight below-making approach to the exhibits awkward-but this may have been a good thing too-preventing public access to the exhibits.

But the curved wall does pose a problem for exhibits like paintings which are flat and anchoring them to the wall is an issue. I was told by a gentle curator that for each exhibition they drill holes in the curved wall anew, and after the exhibition make it up by cement plaster. Which means that a part of wall is destroyed & touched up again for each new exhibition & this has been going on for the last fifty years. It is a wonder that the building shell has survived all this for so long. And it is not only a question of physical damage to the building-it is criminal to treat so sacred a building in such a cruel fashion.

I put this to the curator, and he accepted the fact but shrugged his shoulders in the typical American fashion and said that you must deal with the situation in the best practical fashion. i was wondering why they could not fit in permanent nails so that the walls need not be drilled for every new exhibition, but the idea seemed foreign to him. (It was-I talked to the Asian guard there, who concurred with me-it is only Asians, who seem to see the presence of God in the inanimate!)

The skylight in the centre was too big, and I was wondering the effect of heat built-up. The museum is now air conditioned and they have solved the problem of heat built up by covering the sky-light from top. Not only that, they have also covered the strip of skylight all along the external wall (which gives a distinct shape to the building) and have placed artificial lighting below for the exhibits. This makes the original design redundant, but then skylight is not a good thing for any museum exhibit. The quality of light changes throughout the day, and you can not direct the light to the painting anyway. It could only serve as a general purpose lighting. Even this general purpose lighting, if done in excess, defeats the purpose of the museum-in many museums of this kind you can not see the exhibits properly.

On the other side, the parapet wall is a bit low considering the height-it feels unsafe near the edge. Moreover, the parapet curves outward to confirm with the overall design pattern of each upper floor coming in a bit, which enhances the feeling.

How can the building be a monument to the modern architecture with all these defects? Or is it? Is it a metaphor for all the 20th century buildings obsessed with the form and not the function? And this too, in building designed by FLW? Are we reading the signs right?

I know the building is criticised for these and many such flaws and still stands a testimony to the philosophy of FLW. Like the Chandigarh Assembly building-it paved the way for a new aesthetics for modern architecture. The question is-if it does all this-what do you read in the building now as a student of architecture? I think we need a more detailed discussion on the meaning of Guggenheim Museum in the present context.